Skip to content
9 min read

ESRS Simplification: Seven Weaknesses in the Final Delegated Act

Man in a shirt reviewing printed documents at a desk

In my benchmarking pool of more than 1,000 European CSRD reports, 14 per cent contain no Scope figure at all (as of October 2026). That is the starting point the ESRS simplification lands on: fewer mandatory datapoints, a wider filter for undue cost or effort, and more methodological freedom in greenhouse gas (GHG) accounting. It reduces the burden. It does not make the next reports more comparable.

I submitted a formal response to the draft on 14 May 2026. This article checks my seven points against the final text.

What the final text sets out

The Commission adopted the revised European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) on 3 July 2026 as Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563. It was published in the Official Journal on 21 September 2026, enters into force on 10 November 2026 and applies to financial years starting on or after 1 January 2027. For financial year 2026, companies may choose between the previous and the revised version. According to EFRAG's technical advice of 3 December 2025, mandatory datapoints fall by 61 per cent. Which datapoints remain is covered in my overview of the revised ESRS, the basics in my ESRS guide.

The revised ESRS are easier to apply than the 2023 set in several respects. None of my seven points, however, has been fully resolved.

Seven weaknesses checked against the final text

WeaknessFinal textStatus
1. Undue cost or effort without a justification dutyBalancing in ESRS 1 paragraph 94, reassessment each period (paragraph 95); BP-1 AR 2 j requires disclosure of significant limitations, not a justification per datapointpartly
2. Severity before likelihood only for human rightsESRS 1 paragraph 40 unchangedopen
3. Free choice of GHG boundary without reconciliationApproach must be stated (E1 paragraph 30 b), no reconciliationpartly
4. Secondary microplastics not coveredE2-4 paragraph 16: primary and directly released microplastics, no disclosure for secondaryopen
5. Non-1.5 °C plans without pressure to actE1-1 AR 2 a requires comparison with reference values; scenario analysis for risk identification now voluntary (E1-2 paragraph 17, AR 6); assets at transition risk still require a 1.5 °C scenario (E1-11 paragraph 40 a)partly, loosened elsewhere
6. Fiduciary exemption for asset managersAR 17 and AR 37 unchangedopen
7. No coherence between ESRS and the value chain capParagraph 66 refers to Annex II of Regulation 2026/1560, no coherence clauseopen

Point 1 matters most for comparability. A company that omits datapoints for undue cost or effort now has to disclose that it did, but not justify it per datapoint or say when it will deliver. I proposed a justification with a remediation date that the assurance provider has to challenge.

Point 2 concerns risks with low likelihood and high severity. In a climate risk analysis for a mid-sized German group, hail was exactly such a case: rare, but expensive at a few sites. A filter that simply multiplies likelihood and severity pushes such risks down the list.

Point 3 shows in the data: only 67 per cent of the reports in my pool contain values for all three Scopes, and in 8 per cent of the reports with a Scope 3 figure it is smaller than Scope 1 or Scope 2 (as of October 2026). Three permitted boundaries without reconciliation will not improve that. How to set up E1 reporting consistently is covered in my ESRS E1 implementation guide.

The two gaps with the largest consequences

Greenwashing by omission. Asset managers that hold investments in a fiduciary capacity do not have to report on them. The same firms market funds under Article 8 and Article 9 of the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) with explicit sustainability promises and publish fund-level disclosures. Their own sustainability statement then omits exactly what their sales material promises. That is not a false statement but a permitted gap. I proposed lifting the exemption where products with sustainability claims are marketed. Why omissions are the riskier kind of claim is covered in my article on avoiding greenwashing.

The coherence trap. The ESRS require reporters to disclose information about their value chain. The value chain cap limits what they may request from suppliers with up to 1,000 employees for that purpose, and it leaves out Scope 3, GHG targets and climate risks. Paragraph 66 now refers to the cap, but no rule aligns the two. Companies fill the gap with their own questionnaires, which is exactly what both acts were meant to prevent.

What this means in practice

For companies in CSRD scope: if you use the undue cost filter, document internally for each datapoint why and until when. You have to disclose the limitation anyway, and the assurance review three years from now will ask why.

For asset managers: distributing Article 8 or Article 9 products while staying silent on managed investments in your own statement builds reputational and regulatory risk, even if it is lawful today.

For SMEs in value chains: expect more bespoke questionnaires from customers, not fewer. A dataset based on the voluntary standard answers the capped part; Scope 3 and climate risks need their own answers.

My take

The Commission has made the room for manoeuvre subject to disclosure, but not to justification. That gap decides whether reports from 2027 become more comparable or merely shorter. Companies that bring credible Scope 3 figures and quantified climate risks to a lender or investor stand out, precisely because the standards no longer require them.

FAQ on the ESRS simplification

1. What does the 2026 ESRS simplification change?

The revised European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) were published as Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563. They enter into force on 10 November 2026 and apply to financial years starting on or after 1 January 2027. According to EFRAG's technical advice of 3 December 2025, mandatory datapoints fall by 61 per cent; the regulation itself states no figure.

2. Can companies still use the old ESRS for 2026?

Yes. For financial year 2026, companies may choose between the previous and the revised standards.

3. What is greenwashing by omission?

Not a false statement but a permitted gap: an asset manager markets funds with sustainability promises but does not have to report on those managed investments in its own sustainability statement. The final text keeps this exemption.

4. Do the revised ESRS apply to SMEs?

No. They apply to companies with more than 1,000 employees and more than €450 million net turnover. Smaller companies use the voluntary standard based on VSME, which is linked to the ESRS through the value chain cap.

5. Where can I read the consultation responses?

On the Commission's consultation pages: my response on the revised ESRS (Ares(2026)4623964) and my response on the voluntary standard (Ares(2026)4624010). All other responses are public as well, which makes for decent reading on a long train journey.

Sources
EFRAG. (2025, December 3). EFRAG provides its technical advice on draft simplified ESRS to the European Commission. EFRAG.
European Commission. (2023, July 31). Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/2772 (ESRS). Official Journal of the EU.
European Commission. (2026, July 3). Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563 simplifying the ESRS. Official Journal of the EU, 21 September 2026.
European Commission. (2026, July 3). Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560 (voluntary standard and value chain cap). Official Journal of the EU, 21 September 2026.
Fiegenbaum, J. (2026, May 14). Response on the revised ESRS. Have your say, European Commission.

Johannes Fiegenbaum

Johannes Fiegenbaum

ESG and sustainability consultant based in Hamburg, specialised in VSME reporting, carbon accounting and climate risk analysis. Works with mid-sized companies, investors and financial institutions, and developed the VSME reporting software VSEasy together with clients.

More about